Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. StopTheCatalogs.com may earn a commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no additional cost to you. The free opt-out methods always come first in our guides. See our Privacy Statement for details.

DMAchoice vs PaperKarma vs Catalog Choice: What Works

calendar Jun 6, 2026 · 3 min read · catalog opt out General Method  ·
Share on: linkedin copy

Three Services, Three Different Jobs

DMAchoice covers member mailers through a single registry; Catalog Choice covers individual senders you name one by one; PaperKarma covers anything you can photograph. They sound like competitors, but they actually solve different parts of the same problem — which is why the people who get the best results use all three rather than betting on one. This guide puts them head-to-head on the four things that matter: cost, coverage, how long they take, and where each one quietly fails.

The most common question is the blunt one: does DMAchoice actually work? Yes — with a specific limitation. It suppresses your name from the prospect lists of companies that participate in the registry, which is most large national mailers. It does nothing about companies that aren't members, and nothing about retailers you've personally bought from (they mail you as an existing customer, not a prospect). That limitation is the whole reason the other two services exist.

The head-to-head

  1. DMAchoice — Operated by the Association of National Advertisers at dmachoice.org. Cost: $5 online, $6 by mail, one time. Coverage: member mailers' prospect lists, across catalogs, magazine offers, donation requests, and retail promotions, in one registration. Duration: 10 years. Timeline: allow up to 90 days. Fails when: the sender isn't a member, or you're an existing customer of that brand.

  2. Catalog Choice — A free nonprofit service (The Story of Stuff Project) at CatalogChoice.org. Cost: free. Coverage: a database of nearly 10,000 named senders — you search and opt out of each one individually. Timeline: depends on each retailer's cycle. Fails when: a sender ignores third-party requests (some large retailers no longer honor them), or the catalog simply isn't in the database.

  3. PaperKarma — A paid app at PaperKarma. Cost: subscription (90-day money-back guarantee). Coverage: anything you can photograph — it identifies the sender and files the opt-out for you. Timeline: typically 4–12 weeks per sender. Fails when: a sender is outside its database or refuses third-party opt-outs; you also pay on a subscription basis.

Which one should you start with

If you want the widest sweep for the least effort, start with DMAchoice — one $5 registration suppresses your name across most national mailers for a decade. Add Catalog Choice (free) to knock out specific named catalogs that DMAchoice missed. Then use PaperKarma for the persistent few that survive both — the obscure regional mailers and the catalogs you can't find in either database. That sequence — broad registry, then named-sender list, then photograph-the-rest — is the most efficient order, and it's exactly the four-step master method this site recommends.

The one thing none of them fixes automatically is a retailer you've bought from. For those, you have to use the store's own preference center — see the per-brand guides below.

Frequently asked questions

Is PaperKarma worth it if DMAchoice and Catalog Choice are cheaper or free? It earns its keep on the stubborn remainder — senders not in the free databases, or ones you'd otherwise have to chase by phone. If your mail is all big-name catalogs, the free/cheap pair may be enough on its own.

Why did a catalog ignore my Catalog Choice request? Some large retailers stopped honoring third-party opt-out services and now require you to opt out with them directly. L.L.Bean is a well-known example.

References

Posts in this series