Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. StopTheCatalogs.com may earn a commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no additional cost to you. The free opt-out methods always come first in our guides. See our Privacy Statement for details.

How to Unsubscribe From the Pottery Barn Catalog

calendar Jun 4, 2026 / · 3 min read · catalog opt out Home Goods  ·
Share on: linkedin copy

One List, Several Catalogs

Pottery Barn is part of the Williams-Sonoma family, which means a single purchase can put you on the mailing lists for Pottery Barn, Pottery Barn Kids, PBteen, West Elm, and Williams-Sonoma all at once. That's why opting out of "the Pottery Barn catalog" alone rarely fixes a home-goods mailbox — the same parent company is mailing you under several brand names. The fix is to opt out at the brand level for each one you actually receive, using Pottery Barn's own communication preferences rather than a third-party service.

Unlike some retailers, Pottery Barn does still accept third-party opt-outs, so registry services help here. But going direct is faster and more complete.

How to unsubscribe from the Pottery Barn catalog: step by step

  1. Set your Pottery Barn mailing preferences — On the Pottery Barn website, open Customer Service → Email & Catalog Preferences (the "Mailing Options" page) and request removal from direct-mail advertising. Use their suggested wording — that you prefer not to receive direct mail such as periodic catalogs and mailings — so the correct preference is set.

  2. Call customer service — Phone 800-541-1262 and ask to be removed from the catalog mailing list. Read the source number off your catalog's address label to match the right record.

  3. Repeat for each sister brand — If you also get West Elm, Williams-Sonoma, Pottery Barn Kids, or PBteen, opt out of each separately — they're managed as distinct mailing lists even though they share a parent.

  4. Add Catalog Choice and PaperKarma — Pottery Barn honors Catalog Choice (free), and PaperKarma can file removals for any brand variant that slips through.

What to expect

Plan on up to eight weeks to be fully removed from Pottery Barn's direct-mail list; catalogs already in production will keep arriving for a few weeks as the system updates. If a Pottery Barn catalog is still showing up after two months, it's almost always because a sister-brand list or a second address variant wasn't covered — go back and opt out of that specific brand and address.

Note that email and catalog preferences are separate at Pottery Barn. Unsubscribing from promotional email does not stop the paper catalog, so handle the mailing-preferences step explicitly.

Frequently asked questions

Does opting out of Pottery Barn also stop West Elm and Williams-Sonoma? No. They're sister brands under Williams-Sonoma, Inc., but each maintains its own mailing list. Opt out of every brand you receive.

Is it faster to use opt-out wording than just say "remove me"? Yes — Pottery Barn distinguishes email advertising from direct-mail advertising. State specifically that you want to stop direct mail / catalogs so the right preference is set.

References

  • Pottery Barn. "Catalog Mailing Options," Customer Service section, Pottery Barn website. Retrieved 2026-06-07.
  • The Story of Stuff Project. "Catalog Choice." CatalogChoice.org, https://www.catalogchoice.org/. Retrieved 2026-06-07.
  • Association of National Advertisers. "DMAchoice Mail Preference Service." DMAchoice.org, https://www.dmachoice.org/. Retrieved 2026-06-07.

Posts in this series